Choosing the right sub-compact tractors is a big decision, and it helps to compare your options before pulling the trigger. We’ve put the John Deere 1025R, Kubota BX2380, Kioti CS2210, and Massey Ferguson GC1723E head-to-head to help you make the best choice for your property.
Tractors Power and Performance: 1025R vs BX2380 vs GC1723E vs CS2210
When it comes to raw power, the numbers tell an interesting story. The John Deere 1025R leads the pack with 24 HP and 18 PTO HP, giving you more muscle for demanding jobs. The Kubota BX2380 follows closely with 23 HP and 17.7 PTO HP, while the Massey Ferguson GC1723E delivers 22.5 HP with 18.3 PTO HP. The Kioti CS2210 rounds out the group at 21.1 HP with 18.7 PTO HP.
But horsepower alone doesn’t paint the whole picture. The way each tractor puts that power to the ground makes all the difference. Every model in this comparison features a hydrostatic transmission, which means smooth, clutch-free operation. You control speed with foot pedals rather than shifting gears, and that simplicity matters when you’re learning or when you’re exhausted after a long day.
The 1025R and BX2380 both use two-range HST systems, letting you shift between high and low ranges for different tasks. This gives you better control, whether you’re creeping along with precision work or cruising between jobs. The GC1723E and CS2210 also feature dual-range hydrostatic systems with similar capabilities, keeping all four tractors competitive in this category.
Loader Capacity: The Real Workhorse Test
Here’s where the differences really start to matter. Loader capacity separates these machines more than any other spec. The John Deere 1025R can lift approximately 686 lbs at 24 inches behind the pivot pin, giving it a significant edge over the competition. This extra lifting power makes a real difference when you’re moving rocks, loading firewood, or handling heavy materials.
The Kubota BX2380 lifts 613 lbs with its standard loader, but add the skid steer quick attach, and that drops to just 423 lbs due to the coupler’s weight. That’s a serious consideration if you plan to use quick-attach implements. The Massey Ferguson GC1723E sits in the middle with a lift capacity of around 661 lbs at 24 inches behind pins, while the Kioti CS2210 delivers competitive performance for its size class.
When you’re comparing loader performance, think about your typical tasks. Moving mulch and light dirt? Any of these will work fine. Handling large landscape boulders or heavy pallets? The 1025R’s extra capacity becomes valuable insurance. At FridayParts, we stock replacement hydraulic components for all these models, helping you keep that lifting power strong year after year.
Operator Comfort and Controls
You’ll spend hours in the seat, so comfort matters more than you might think. The John Deere 1025R features twin-pedal HST controls – separate pedals for forward and reverse. This setup reduces fatigue compared to treadle pedals because you’re not constantly flexing your foot and ankle. The BX2380 uses a treadle pedal system, which many operators actually prefer once they get used to it. Personal preference plays a big role here.
Both the 1025R and BX2380 offer premium operator stations with high-back seats and armrests. The newer BX models have addressed earlier ergonomic complaints with a tilting steering wheel and better-positioned loader controls integrated into the fender. The GC1723E provides a comfortable, strategically positioned seat without armrests, which works fine for the tractor’s compact size. The Kioti CS2210 features an ergonomic operator station with generous fore/aft travel and easy-to-reach controls that minimize fatigue.
All four tractors include cruise control, letting you maintain steady speeds during mowing or transport. They also feature 4WD engaged with simple levers, power steering for easy maneuvering, and foldable ROPS that clear standard 7-foot garage doors. Browse our tractor parts inventory for seat upgrades and comfort accessories if you want to customize your setup.
Mower Deck Attachment Systems
If mowing is a priority, the attachment system becomes a major decision point. The John Deere 1025R’s AutoConnect mid-mount deck stands out as perhaps its biggest advantage. You literally drive over the deck, and it connects automatically – no tools, no struggling, no lifting. Detaching takes seconds. This convenience factor can’t be overstated if you frequently switch between mowing and other tasks.
The Kubota BX2380 uses an “easy-over” deck system that’s improved significantly in recent years. It’s not fully automatic like the Deere, but it’s still much faster than older designs. You’ll use ramps to drive over the deck and make simple connections. Most owners get it down to 5-10 minutes after some practice. The GC1723E features a 60-inch mid-mount drive-over deck with shaft drive and 3 overlapping blades operating at 2000 rpm. The CS2210 also offers mid-mount mower compatibility with easy height adjustment controls.
Deck size options vary by model. The 1025R offers 54-inch and 60-inch options, while the BX2380 provides similar choices. The GC1723E’s standard 60-inch deck covers more ground per pass, which matters on larger properties. The CS2210 accommodates multiple deck sizes suited to residential applications.
Pricing and Value Proposition
Budget matters, and there’s meaningful variation here. The Kubota BX2380 typically comes in at the most competitive price point, often running $1,000-$2,000 less than a comparably equipped 1025R. Kubota also frequently offers better financing terms – sometimes 0% for 84 months compared to John Deere’s 50-60 month zero-percent offers. The Massey Ferguson GC1723E generally prices between $12,000 and $16,000, depending on configuration and dealer. The Kioti CS2210 sits in the value category with competitive base pricing around $13,000-$14,000 for basic configurations.
However, resale value tells another story. John Deere tractors hold their value exceptionally well. A 5-year-old 1025R with reasonable hours still commands strong prices in the used market. Kubota also retains value well, though typically not quite as aggressively as Deere. Massey Ferguson and Kioti tractors offer solid value retention, particularly in markets where dealer support is strong.
Consider the total cost of ownership, not just the purchase price. Warranty coverage varies – Kubota typically offers longer powertrain warranties (6 years/2,000 hours) compared to John Deere’s standard coverage. The GC1723E comes with a 2-year or 2,000-hour warranty covering drivetrain, hydraulics, and electronics. The CS2210 also provides competitive warranty protection.
Common Issues and Real-World Performance
Let’s talk honestly about what owners report. The John Deere 1025R has a loyal following, but some users mention the loader can only perform one function at a time – you lift or curl, not both simultaneously. This slows down certain tasks. Some earlier models also had idle speeds around 1,800 rpm, which felt rough compared to competitors’ idling at 1,000-1,300 rpm.
The Kubota BX2380 owners sometimes report concerns about the vulnerable HST fan on older models, though newer generations have improved. The loader’s lower lift capacity frustrates some users, especially when comparing directly to the 1025R. However, the backhoe attachment (on BX23S models) runs smoother than the Deere counterpart according to many side-by-side comparisons.
The Massey Ferguson GC1723E has received reports from owners about bucket collapsing issues when tilting, along with reduced performance and increased operating temperature in some cases. The tractor’s lower ground clearance can be limiting on rough terrain. The Kioti CS2210 earns praise for its quiet operation – one of the quietest diesels in the class – but has a smaller dealer network than the big three brands.
Parts availability matters for long-term ownership. John Deere, Kubota, and Massey Ferguson all have extensive dealer networks and strong parts support. Kioti’s network is growing, but may require more planning for parts in some regions.
Which Sub-Compact Tractor Wins?
There’s no universal “best” choice – it depends on your specific needs. The John Deere 1025R excels if you value loader capacity, the AutoConnect mower, and maximum resale value. You’ll pay more upfront, but you’re getting premium features and engineering. The Kubota BX2380 makes sense if initial cost and financing terms matter most, and you don’t need maximum lifting capacity. It’s a proven workhorse with a massive following.
The Massey Ferguson GC1723E offers a solid middle-ground option with good PTO power and versatility for those who prefer the MF brand. The Kioti CS2210 appeals to budget-conscious buyers who want quality features like quiet operation and ergonomic design without paying for a premium nameplate.
Consider your dealer network, too. A nearby dealer with great service can make a bigger difference than a few extra horsepower. And remember that quality aftermarket parts from suppliers like FridayParts help you maintain any of these machines affordably over the long haul.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which has better lift capacity: 1025R or BX2380?
The John Deere 1025R significantly outperforms the Kubota BX2380 in loader lift capacity. The 1025R lifts approximately 686 lbs at 24 inches behind the pivot pin, while the BX2380 lifts 613 lbs with its standard loader or just 423 lbs with the skid steer quick attach coupler. If you regularly handle heavy materials like rocks, logs, or full pallets, the 1025R’s advantage becomes very practical.
Is the John Deere AutoConnect deck worth the premium price?
For many owners, absolutely yes. The AutoConnect deck saves 5-10 minutes every time you attach or remove the mower, which adds up fast if you mow weekly. The system is tool-free and nearly foolproof, making it easier for multiple family members to operate. However, if you leave the deck on most of the season and rarely switch implements, this advantage matters less.
Which tractor offers the best financing?
Kubota typically offers more aggressive financing terms, often featuring 0% APR for 84 months compared to John Deere’s typical 50-60 month zero-percent offers. Massey Ferguson and Kioti dealers also run competitive financing promotions seasonally. However, actual terms vary by dealer, region, and your credit profile, so always shop around and negotiate.
Can these sub-compact tractors handle a backhoe attachment?
Yes, all four tractors can be equipped with backhoe attachments. The Kubota BX23S comes standard with a backhoe and is praised for smooth operation. The John Deere 1025R can add the 260B backhoe, which offers slightly more power but less smooth hydraulics, according to user comparisons. Both the GC1723E and CS2210 have compatible backhoe options from their respective manufacturers, suitable for light excavation work.
Where can I find quality replacement parts for these tractors?
FridayParts stocks a comprehensive range of aftermarket parts for all major tractor brands, including John Deere, Kubota, Massey Ferguson, and Kioti. From filters and belts to hydraulic components and engine parts, we offer OEM-quality replacements at competitive prices with fast shipping to minimize your downtime.
